It’s hard for me to separate modern notions of ambition from what people would have described as ambition in the 17th century. The way I perceive this trait is from the context of a western capitalist society. But even that is hard to define. A person is not deemed ambitious by their status in society. For example, a person might build a company from the ground up and become incredibly successful, and we would call this person ambitious. But when he dies, he passes the business on to his son (who may or may not be qualified to run a company), and we would likely attribute the son’s success not to ambition, but instead to nepotism. In another instance, a young woman from a low-income household might get an entry level job in the mail-room of some company, and by hard work she eventually gets promoted to department manager. Ambition is not distinctly defined in our society, but tends to be correlated with upward mobility. But it varies in degree and kind, and the desired reward is not always financial.
According to Oxford folk ambition is “the ardent (in early usage, inordinate) desire to rise to high position, or to attain rank, influence, distinction or other preferment.” And to me this is interesting, since the trait is defined by the desire for rank or prestige, etc. Whereas I would prefer to define the word by those who attempt to raise their status, whether they fail or succeed. Still, etymologically, the earliest uses (starting in 1340) group ambition with pride, vein glory and other negative traits. Even Shakespeare writes in King Henry VIII, “Cromwel, I charge thee, fling away Ambition, By that sinne fell the Angels.” Ambition, like hubris, is the downfall of heroes and the death of kings. Of course, we can see this in Macbeth and Hamlet, but is it always negative?
In the United States we laud ambitious young people and encourage them to attain the heights of whatever it is they are reaching for. Was there not some equivalent in the Elizabethan era? Isn’t that what makes gallant knights go off to war? Was Shakespeare infected with unholy ambition? Perhaps ambition is only a valiant trait in a capitalist republic/democracy.
Ambition can also be the object of desire, like a lover or a crown. I suspect that in Shakespeare’s works we will discover the troubling nature of ambition. We will see it destabilize society, and we will see characters compromise their beliefs (or society’s beliefs) over the objects of their ambitions. But I think that looking at these plays and poems through this prism will also reveal that Shakespeare’s era is a more fluid time than it at first seems. Shakespeare himself represents at least some degree of upward mobility.
"For I am nothing if not critical." -- Othello 2.1.119
Showing posts with label Blog 1. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Blog 1. Show all posts
Thursday, January 23, 2014
Thursday, January 9, 2014
Blog Post #1--Fate
Fate consistently surfaced as a major theme in the works presented in my Reading Historically I class last semester. From Beowulf to Shakespeare's own Richard III, an argument could be made that fate had created the sequence of events in each piece and played a significant part in the roles and development of various characters. Using Richard III as an example, Richard states in Act I, Scene 1 the he is "determined to be the villain." This statement proved rather vexing due to the dual meaning of "determined." Did Richard possess a deep desire to paint himself as the story's villain, or was he the product or even the victim of some preordained cycle or prophecy. I personally understood "determined" to mean the latter--hence the reason I have chosen "fate" as my topic. I expect that this theme features hugely in Shakespeare's works, especially seeing as it is a concept consistently used in English literature, such as the "wheel of fortune" present in both Le Morte Darthur and Richard III. I am interested in tracking it because I believe the way one views the presence of fate can significantly change his or her perspective of a Shakespearean title. If fate indeed lurks in the backround of a play, it can, for example, potentially change how one views the charaters. With Richard, I personally felt sorry for him in a sense, as he appeared destined for his terrible role due to some plan from an omnipotent being. While I would not argue that Richard is a likeable character or that he should be viewed as such, his unhappy fortune made him, at least in my eyes, more pitiable, and I believe this added to his depth. Was he happy with his role in English society or did he view himself as a victim? This is just one interesting question that this concept brings up, and I believe that, especially with the ever-growing popularity of Calvinism and predestination throughout Europe, Shakespeare certainly could have taken advantage of this popular religious ideology and incorporated it into his works.
So what exactly is "fate"? Deriving from the Latin "fatum", which translates "that which has been spoken", and is related to the Old English word wyrd, which the OED defines as "the principle, power, or agency by which events are predetermined; fate, destiny." The word fate itself was first used in literature by Geoffry Chaucer in 1374. The OED most generally defines fate as "The principle, power, or agency by which, according to certain philosophical and popular systems of belief, all events, or some events in particular, are unalterably predetermined from eternity. [It is] Often personified." It goes on to explain that fate can also be viewed as "the goddess of fate or destiny; in Homer", or "the three goddesses supposed to determine the course of human life." Shakespeare uses these three defintions. One definition that also caught my attention came in the eighteenth century, defining it as "an instrument of death or destruction." I hope to be able to find and develop my understanding of this concept throughout the semester.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)